Activia

Activia is a brand of yogurt owned by Groupe Danone ("The Dannon Company" in the United States) and introduced in France in 1987. As of 2013, Activia is present in more than 70 countries and on all 5 continents. Activia is classified as a functional food,^[1] designed to improve digestive health.^[2]

History

In the 1980s, Danone researchers took interest in bifidobacteria. They developed a specific strain that can survive in the acidic medium of yogurt. In addition to traditional yogurt bacteria, they decided to add a probiotic strain:Bifidus Actiregularis. Activia products thus contain Bifidobacterium animalis DN 173,010, a proprietary strain of Bifidobacterium, a probiotic which is marketed by Dannon under the trade names Bifidus Regularis, Bifidus Actiregularis, Bifidus Digestivum and Bifidobacterium Lactis.^[3] Danone launched Activia in France in 1987 under the "Bio" brand name.^[4]

Introductions into new countries

• 1987: France
• 1988: Belgium, Spain, and the United Kingdom
• 1989: Italy
• 2002: Russia, Japan
• 2003: America
• 2004: Canada
• 2005: Africa, China, and the United States.^[5]
• 2011: Australia.^[6] Activia is the first probiotic brand of yogurts sold in the United States.

By 2006, the brand was operating in 22 countries. In 2013, it was sold in more than 70 countries.^[7]

Products in 2013

A Russian Activia bottle

Activia products are sold with different textures (set or firm, stirred, drinkable...) and in flavors adapted to local consumer preferences. The product line varies by country. Most Activia yogurts contain real fruit.

America

United States

• Activia: a women's yogurt that consists of cherry, prune, strawberry banana, peach, mixed berry, blueberry, strawberry, vanilla^[8]
• Activia Light: strawberry banana, key lime, raspberry, blueberry, peach, strawberry, vanilla
• Activia Harvest Picks: cherry, mixed berry, peach, strawberry
• Activia Breakfast Blend: apple cinnamon, maple and brown sugar, banana bread, vanilla
• Activia Fiber: peach cereal, strawberry cereal, vanilla cereal
• Activia Drinks: mango, peach, prune, strawberry, strawberry banana
• Activia 24 oz. Tubs: vanilla light, plain, vanilla

Canada

• Activia: blueberry, vanilla, raspberry, strawberry, strawberry rhubarb, prune, peach, cherry, lemon, plain unsweetened, plain sweetened, apple and blackberry^[9]
• Activia source of fiber: strawberry kiwi cereal, red fruits cereal, peach cereal, vanilla cereal, blueberry cereal
• Activia fat free: strawberry, vanilla, raspberry, peach
• Drinkable Activia: strawberry, vanilla, mixed berry

Brazil

In Brazil, both yogurt and yogurt-drinks are available. In addition to the usual worldwide fruit flavors, honey with carrot is also available. The "light" line is marketed as "0%" fat.^[10]

Europe

In Bulgaria, Croatia, and Romania the products include semi-solid yogurts (plain, cereal, strawberry, peach and prune) and yogurt drinks (plain, cereal, strawberry-kiwi and cherry-vanilla).

In Finland the Activia brand includes fruit and natural yogurt as well as yogurt drinks. Lactose free forms of the yogurt are also sold.

In France, semi-solid yogurt and yogurt with fruit layers are available. Unique flavors include coconut. The "light" series is marketed as "0%" fat.^[11]

In Spain there are over 56 different flavors. Following a European law which forbids non-organic food to be labeled "Bio", Danone changed Spanish "Bio"-branded products to the "Activia" brand in order to comply with the law.

In Russia, the products include yogurt, yogurt drinks and kefir, a drink traditionally popular in Commonwealth of Independent States countries. The fiber yogurt series includes three muesli flavors in addition to the oat cereal flavor found in the US and UK. Drinkable yogurt variations include pineapple and dried apricot, among others.

United Kingdom and Ireland

In Britain and Republic of Ireland, the Activia range includes :

• Fruit: mango, cranberry, fig, kiwi, apricot, prune, rhubarb, strawberry, cereals fibre, pear^[12]
• 0% Fat Free: peach, cherry, forest fruit, mandarin, mango, blueberry, pineapple, raspberry, strawberry, vanilla
• Single pot fat free: peach, cherry, raspberry, strawberry, banana toffee and biscuity bits, juicy pineapple
• Fruit Layer: prune, raspberry
• Natural : 500 Gram pot
• Intensely Creamy Classics : raspberry, cherry, peaches, strawberry, lemon, vanilla
• Intensely Creamy Temptations: caramel, coconut
• Greek style: berries, lemon, honey
• Breakfast pouring yogurt: natural, vanilla, strawberry.^[13]
• Breakfast pots (with crunchy clusters): vanilla, honey, peach

Africa

In the Republic of South Africa, flavors include pear, mango, dried apricot, kiwi, fiber and prune.

Australia

• 4-Pack: strawberry, natural, vanilla, fig, berries, mango^[14]
• Dessert: strawberry shortcake, apple strudel, passionfruit cheesecake
• Favourites: vanilla berries mango, berries strawberry blueberry
• Large Tub: strawberry, vanilla
• Pouring: strawberry, mango, natural, vanilla
• Singles: berries, strawberry, mango

Market

Lactobacillus bulgaricus, also from a sample of Activia yogurt.  The numbered ticks are 11 micrometres apart.

With its launch in France in the 1980s, Activia pioneered the probiotic spoonable yogurt market.^[15]

In 2006, Activia sales reached $130 million, in the US alone. The following year, sales increased by 50% in the US market.^[16]

In 2009, sales of Activia reach €2.6 billion globally, with key markets in Europe and the United States.^[15] Activia's popularity in the United States is due to the growing public demand for natural products as well as the growing market of probiotics that came into vogue in the late 1990s.^[17]

In 2010, Activia dominated the probiotic dairy sector.^[18] The success of Activia has increased the health yogurt market.^[19]

Activia, Actimel and Danonino account for more than half of the total worldwide yogurt sales.^[20] Activia is a more than 2 billion-dollar brand which owes its success to the health benefit claim.^[19]

In 2011, Activia is the largest global fresh dairy brand in the world (Nielsen data). The probiotic yogurt market is valued at €4 billion.^[21]

Activia is present in more than 70 countries and is one of the major brands of the Danone Group.^[7]

The probiotics market

Activia products are considered as functional foods. These foods are enriched with probiotics and provide health benefits when consumed in adequate amounts. The positive effects depend on the specific strain, and its dose.^[22]

In 2003, the probiotics (also called functional foods) market was worth $9.9 billion.^[23] These products are also heavily marketed and more expensive than non-probiotic dairy products.

In 2009, in United Kingdom, 60% of households regularly bought probiotic drinks. The market there is currently worth £164m per year.^[24]

Consumers are willing to pay for products that provide health benefits.^[25] Activia products, that are considered as functional foods, are priced about two dollars higher than other yogurts.

Innovation

In 2011, in Germany, Danone moved from polystyrene to PLA Ingeo, a new material for its Activia yogurt cup. This packaging is made of plastic from plants, not oil. To develop this innovative material, the French manufacturer worked closely with NatureWorks. Danone and NatureWorks also want to achieve the International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC) designation for this new Activia packaging. This packaging change has been implemented for about 80% of the volume of all Activia products in the German market.^[26]

The aim of this switch is to reduce the packaging carbon footprint by 25% and to use 43% less fossil resources.^[27]

Communication

Since Activia's launch, the Danone Group focused Activia communication on probiotics and health benefits. The WHO defines probiotics as "live microorganisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer a health benefit on the host". Consumers bought Activia products mostly for its medicinal qualities.^[28]

In 2010, Dannon partnered with actress Jamie Lee Curtis to promote Activia products.^[29] On the screen, the audience could read "scientifically proven" to reduce irregularity. According to the brand, Activia "helps regulate your digestive system" when eaten on a daily basis.^[30] Danone used health claims as a marketing tool.^[31]

But Danone has been accused of deceptive advertising.^[32]

Further the US litigation and the EU health claims law, and just before the decision of the EFSA on Activia, Danone thus decided to change Activia communication and marketing. Advertising does not talk about health benefits any more, but about pleasure and taste.^[33] On Danone's website, one can read : "Drinking and eating are, first and foremost, a source of pleasure, and while the initial purchase of a product may be motivated by a health benefit, in the majority of cases, a repeat purchase is motivated by the taste".^[34]

Debates surrounding health claims on probiotic foods

Some experts say that there is evidence that probiotic strains reduce diarrhea, irritable bowel syndrome and duration of colds.^[35][36] But others argue that their benefits are not certain.^[23]

The US FDA pressed charges for false advertising.

According to Danone, Activia is based on 17 scientific studies.^[21][37] But according to CBS News, two of these studies were not statistically significant compared to the placebo groups^[38] and six others didn't show a statistically significant improvement in transit time.^[39]

The EU health claims law

In 2006, a European regulation demanded that health food companies come up with the scientific evidence to back their labeling and advertising.^[40] Member states were asked to submit health claims from manufacturers who had to wait for the approval of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). EFSA currently verifies all functional foods claims.^[24] Most of the time, EFSA rejects companies' claims due to the lack of scientific evidence.^[41]

In 2010, following a stream of negative opinions from EFSA for other health claims, Dannon decided to withdraw claims on Activia.^[24]

Controversies in the United States

Litigation in 2010

Streptococcus thermophilus, also from the same sample of Activia yogurt.  Numbered ticks are 11 micrometres apart.

In its marketing for Activia, Danone claimed that Bifidobacterium animalis relieves irregularity.

In the 2010 Activia TV commercials, a voiceover explains : "Activia eaten every day is clinically proven to help regulate your digestive system in two weeks”. Danone said it had scientific evidence to back up its assertions.^[42]

But according to the Federal Trade Commission, commercials and claims on Activia packages are deceptive and Danone exaggerates the yogurt's health benefits.^[43] In its 2010 charges against Danone, the FTC stated that "Eating one serving of Activia daily is not clinically proven to relieve temporary irregularity and help with slow intestinal transit time".^[38] In fact, consumers must eat three servings of Activia each day to obtain health benefits.^[42]

In December 2010, The Danone Company settled allegations of false advertising. In the settlement, Danone dropped its claims of the health benefits of its Activia yogurt.^[44] The company thus agreed to stop advertising that Activia yogurt improves motility, unless the ad conveys that three servings must be eaten per day to obtain these benefits. Danone therefore removed the words "clinically" and "scientifically proven" from Activia products.^[45]

Danone agreed to pay US$21 million to 39 states that had coordinated investigations with the FTC.^[46][47] In response to a similar lawsuit in Canada, Danone agreed to settle the suit by paying compensation and modifying its advertising.^[48]

Class action in 2008–2009

A class action lawsuit filed in Los Angeles federal court on 25 January 2008, argued that Danone's own studies failed to support its advertised claims.^[49] The class action suit accused Danone of mounting a massive false advertising campaign to convince consumers to buy Activia products because of their health benefits.^[50]

In a statement in response to the lawsuit, Danone stated that it "strongly disagrees with the allegations in the lawsuit" and that it makes all scientific studies about its products available to the public, following the established method of peer-review and publication.^[51] According to the group:"All of Dannon's claims for Activia and DanActive are completely supported by peer-reviewed science and are in accordance with all laws and regulations".^[52]

In 2009, as a part of the settlement, Danone agreed to create a $35 million fund to reimburse unsatisfied consumers who had bought its Activia and DanActive yogurts.^[53]

Danone spokespeople deny the claims of the lawsuit and admitted no wrongdoing as part of the settlement, which was agreed to in order to avoid the distraction and expense of litigation.^[54] As of September 2012, this fund has only paid out about US$1 million in reimbursements to consumers.^[48]

Litigation in Canada in 2009

In October 2009, Danone was sued in Quebec Superior Court over the nature of the health claims in its advertising.^[48] The company had asserted that Activia yogurt could improve digestion or prevent the common cold.^[48] In September 2012, the parties elected to settle the case; Danone agreed to modify its advertising claims, but was not forced to admit wrongdoing.^[48] Consumers who purchased Activia yogurt between 1 April 2009 and 6 Nov 2012 had 90 days to request compensation between C$15 to C$50, based on the quantity purchased.^[48]

References

External links

• whatisbifidusregularis.org/ – An analysis of the terms Bifidus Actiregularis, Bifidus Regularis, Bifidus Digestivum, L. Casei Immunitass and their variants, as well as the marketing strategy, and information about the potential health benefits of live yogurts.
• Danone – The manufacturer of Activia
• Dannon – Danone US subsidiary

Groupe Danone
Corporate directors:	Bruno Bonnell Richard Goblet d'Alviella Michel David-Weill Emmanuel Faber Jean Laurent Hirokatsu Hirano Bernard Hours Christian Lauble Hakan Mogren Jacques Nahmlas Benoît Potier Franck Riboud Jacques Vincent
Brands:	Actimel (DanActive in US) Activia Alpro Brown Cow (yogurt) Dannon Danimals Earthbound Farm Evian Horizon Organic International Delight Land O'Lakes Lattella Michel et Augustin Nutricia Oikos Provamel Silk So Delicious Stonyfield Farm Vega Volvic Wallaby Organic Yogurt
Divisions:	Fresh Dairy Products Infant Nutrition Waters Medical Nutrition WhiteWave Foods