Kincardine O'Neil Hospital, Aberdeenshire

Hospital of St Mary; and Hospital of St Erchard
St Machar's Cathedral
East end of adjoining Church of St Erchard (ruins) with lancet windows and internal aumbries.
Location in Kincardine O'Neil within Aberdeenshire
Geography
Location	Kincardine O'Neil, Aberdeenshire, Scotland
Coordinates	57°05′09″N 2°40′28″W / 57.0859°N 2.6744°W / 57.0859; -2.6744Coordinates: 57°05′09″N 2°40′28″W / 57.0859°N 2.6744°W / 57.0859; -2.6744
Organisation
Care system	Medieval Sub-Monastic care
Hospital type	Medieval Hospital
Patron	Probably Bishop Adam de Kald or Bishop Gilbert de Stirling or Alan the Durward, Justiciar of Scotland
History
Founded	c1225x1230
Closed	c. Before 1450
Demolished	Before 1400
Links
Other links	Hospitals in medieval Scotland

Ruins of St Erchard's Church adjacent to the hospital site in Kincardine O'Neil

Kincardine O'Neil Hospital was founded in the 13th century in the village of Kincardine O'Neil in Scotland.^[1][2] Almost certainly it served as a traveler's inn and as a hospice for elderly and "poor" men. The hospital was situated adjacent to a bridge over the River Dee and may have been a chantry^{[Note 1]} for the early Bishops of Mortlach (See Bishop of Aberdeen).^[3] Remains of a building can be seen abutted to the Auld Parish Church in Kincardine O'Neil.^{[4][Note 2]} This building may have been a later or second hospital. It is also possible that these ruins may have been part of St Erchard's Church - a.k.a. St Marys' or the Auld Kirk.

History

East end of the Church showing the lancet windows. To the right (North) of the right hand window are the remains of an aumbry or wall-press.

There is no certainty with regard to the Hospital or its location. The first reference to a hospital being built comes from the 1233 Charter by Alan the Durward. Confirmatory evidence can be found in 1296 in the Second Ragman Roll.^{[Note 3]} On 28 August 1296 " …Wautier master of the hospital of Kincardine ou Neel …" signed the Roll at Berwick on Tweed.^{[5][Note 4]} Two possible sites have been identified. Most likely, it was founded by Alan or Thomas Durward between 1241 and 1244 abutting St Erchard's Church.^{[Note 5]} It was later built near St Mary's Church – the "Auld Kirk" in Kincardine O'Neil. In 1330 the hospital and its church was erected into a prebend of Aberdeen Cathedral. It may have stood in a field known locally as "Bladernach" near a 19th-century ferryboat station on the river Dee at NO 5874 9933. There was no local knowledge of Bladernach in June 1972 when visited by the Ordnance Survey. The following description comes from Places of Worship in Scotland:^[7]

East gable end plan of Church showing internal windows of the hospital and the 3 aumbries. [Based on details in Simpson (1968)]

The church is thought to stand on, or near, the site of the first church established by St Erchard, the patron saint of Kincardine O'Neil, who brought Christianity here in the 5th century. He was taught at nearby Banchory by St Ternan. The church is located near a river (as common in early Christian sites), in this case the River Dee. There was an important river crossing point here, on the main route between Strathmore and Mar. The current church remains are thought to date to the 14th century. It was recorded that the church was built as a gift by Duncan, Earl of Fife. Alexander Kyninmund, Bishop of Aberdeen, rebuilt the church some time in the mid 14th century. A hospital was attached to the east of the church (thought to be in 1330) but was demolished some time before the church itself went out of use, leaving just the foundation stones (There was also an earlier hospital site in Kincardine O'Neil - see other site, 'Kincardine O'Neil Hospital Site'.). The church became ruinous after a new church was built in 1862. The interior was later converted into burial plots. The graveyard surrounding the church has many gravestones, mostly from the 19th century.

Historical evidence

East wall of the ruined hospital in Kincardine O'Neil

North wall of the ruined hospital in Kincardine O'Neil

The most comprehensive archaeological survey of the Church and the remains of the hospital are found in Douglas Simpson's book.^[8] In this he identifies the lancet windows in the east gable as strong evidence for the existence of the abutted building - the hospital. His argument is that the residents of the hospital - both travellers and the sick or needy would be able to hear Mass from the Church through the windows. The windows, when viewed from the outside of the church ruins (the east end) are clearly internal windows. See the photograph alongside. Douglas Simpson writes as follows:

on the outside of the present east gable are three aumbries ... and above this the gable is traversed by a scarcement for a floor. ... on the other side of the inserted windows are the sides of two original windows opening into the church. ... There can be little doubt the eastern ... portion of the building contained the hospital, a two storied annex of which the upper room will have formed the dormitory in which bed-ridden inmates would have herd services … a somewhat similar structural association of hospital and chapel is known in Belgium… or in the Preceptory of the Knights Templar at Torphican in Midlothian. (p170)

The definitive account of medieval hospitals in Scotland by Cowan & Easson concurs with this assessment.^[9]

Circumstantial evidence with regard to the location of the hospital being abutted to the church comes from several other medieval hospitals. In England, the monastic infirmary at Christ Church Canterbury; the infirmary at St Mary Chichester; St Bartholomew, Chatam and St James Dulwich are built with an infirmary abutting the respective chapels. The infirmary hall of St Mary Magdalene at Glastonbury also follows this structure.^[10]

The 19th-century volume Registrum Episcopatus Aberdonensis provides further evidence.^[11]

Registrum Episcopatus Aberdonensis

Alan Durward is recorded making provision for an existing Hospital, probably founded by his father Thomas de Lundin or Thomas Durward.^{[Note 6]} The first occasion is in 1233 when he makes a grant of a "davach/davoch" of land called Slutheluthy to support the Hospital.^{[Note 7]} The 1845 transcription into Latin reads:

"….Alanus Hostiarius omnibus amicis et hominibus suis salutem Sciant presentes et futuri me dedisse concessisse et hac presenti carta mea confirmasse Deo et beate Marie et hospitali eiusdem genetricis Dei sito iuxta pontem quem pater meus fecit construi super Dee et fratribus in eodem hospitali Deo seruientibus et seruituris in perpetuum in puram et perpetuam elemosinam ad sustentationem eorundem et pauperum receptionem unam dauacham terre que dictur Sutheluthy per suas rectas diuisas et cum omnibus iustis pertinenciis suis et ecclesiam de Kyncardyn in Marr cum omnibus iustis pertinenciis suis Quare uolo et concedo ut predictum hospitale et fratres in eo seruientes Deo et seruituri in perpetuum predictam ecclesiam et predictam terram habeant tenneant et possideant in puram et perpetuam elemosinam per suas rectas diuisas et cum onmibus iustis pertinenciis suis in terris et aquis in bosco et plano in pratis et pascuis in moris et marresiis in lacubus et piscariis in viis et semitis in feris et auibus in stagnis et molendinis adeo libere quiete plenarie et honorifice sicut aliqua elemosina in regno Scotie liberus quietius plenius honorificentius ab aliqua domo religiosa habetur tenetur et possidetur …"

This charter makes it clear that Thomas Durward. Alan Durward's father, had the hospital built at some time before his death in 1231. The hospital appears to have been run by "brothers" and its function was to shelter the poor – "pauperum receptionem".There is no precise location for the Hospital:

"… me dedisse concessisse et hac presenti carta mea confirmasse Deo et beate Marie et hospitali eiusdem genetricis Dei sito iuxta pontem quem pater meus fecit construi super Dee et fratribus in eodem hospitali Deo seruientibus et seruituris in perpetuum in puram et perpetuam elemosinam ad sustentationem eorundem et pauperum receptionem …"

In Summary, this translates to indicate that the gift of land at Sutheluthy is to support the Hospital dedicated to St Mary that is located close to the bridge over the river Dee erected by his father.

A further charter of Alan Durward is dated 1250 ^[12] announces that he has granted to the brothers of the hospital at Kincardine O'Neil two davachs of land called Sudluyth and Kincardine O'Neil (together with two lands within the davach of Kincardine O'Neil, called Pathkellok and Garslogay). An interpretation of the text is that Alan Durward is the founder of the hospital, and the boundaries of the lands are described in detail, mainly by reference to streams.^[13] It also mentions that with the consent of Bishop Peter of Aberdeen and the Cathedral chapter the hospital has received a grant of the church of Kincardine O'Neil with all its pertinents, and two acres containing the church of Lumphanan, with the right of patronage and its chapel of Forthery. These grants are apparently made in return for the establishment of a chantry for the salvation of Alan himself, his forebears and heirs. Alan undertakes a forinsec service to the King for these lands, for which the remainder of his land of O'Neil is to answer in perpetuity. He also prescribes brief rules for replacing the brothers and the master of the hospital (leaving it largely to them, but subject to subsequent presentation to himself for his heirs). The document is sealed at Inverurie. A subscription by Alexander, Bishop of Aberdeen, in 1330 on the creation of a cathedral prebend, states that he understands none of the above to have been vitiated or abolished ('non viciatam nec in aliqua sui parte abolitam').

The following year, 1251^[11] there was a papal bull from Innocent IV 'to his beloved sons the master and brothers of the hospital of the poor at Kincardonel'. They have told him about the grants from Alan Durward, with the consent of the Bishop of Aberdeen. He now confirms them with his apostolic authority, which no one is to infringe.

These three charters taken together suggest that Alan Durward founded the hospital. The location of the hospital is not precise.

Other evidence

The paper by Derek Hall includes a comprehensive list of Scottish Hospitals.^[14] In the 19th century Andrew Jervise looked for the hospital; he concludes as follows:

no trace remains of the hospital which Alan the Durward founded here, and endowed with considerable property, about 1233. Tradition says that the hospital stood in a field called Bladernach, between the village of Kincardine O'Neil and the present ferryboat station on the Dee. Alan's father erected a stone bridge near the latter place, in connection with the great thoroughfare from the south to the north, by Cairn-o'-Mounth ...(1875)

^[15]

The Cairn-o'-Mounth is a "Heritage Path" ^[16] or Drovers' road.^{[Note 8]}

Evidence from the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland

Site plan of church ruins and the hospital. [Based on details in Simpson (1968)]

Plan of Auld Kirk in Kincardine O'Neil with ruins to East

RCAHMS ^[17] provides a summary of the architectural evidence on the history of the hospital. Across a number of documents they report:

The remains of the former parish church dedicated to St Erchard and the Virgin Mary, which appears from documentary evidence to have been a minster in origin.^[18] St Erchard is said to have been a local disciple of St Ternan ^[19] and to be buried in the church. The ruin, of small stones and run lime was repaired and stripped of ivy etc in 1931 to reveal possible 14th century detail including a fine walled-up north door and lancet windows. The granite belfry probably dates from about 1640. The date of foundation of the church is not known but it passed into the possession of the hospital in its foundation before 1231. Foundations which extend 22 meters east of the east gable and architectural peculiarities of the gable itself suggest that the hospital may have adjoined the church on the east. Two windows in the upper part of the gable look into the church as if from an upper floor of the adjoining building as occurred in some monastic buildings in order that sick persons might hear the service. In this case the lancet windows in the east gable would be later insertions, probably dating from the period when the adjoining building was removed. They may in fact have belonged to that building. The church was in use until 1861 when a new church was built. The roof was removed in 1862 and in 1869 the interior was divided into private burial grounds for the ministers and certain of the heritors. Granted with all its pertinents to the hospital of Kincardine O'Neil by its founder, Alan Durward, before 1231, this grant was confirmed in 1250. Along with this church apparently passed its four pendicles of Glentanar, Lumphanan, Cluny and Midmar. The last two of these may, however, have been granted to the hospital independently and were served by vicars in 1274, the hospital master then being taxed 'pro omnibus eclesiis'. In 1330 the hospital with its annexed chapels was erected with the consent of Duncan, earl of Fife, into a prebend of Aberdeen cathedral by Bishop Alexander de Kyninmund. The residual fruits of this prebend with its four annexed chapels were appropriated in 1501 to the Chapel Royal at Stirling, provision being made for vicar pensioners, but it is doubtful whether this was effective. The prebend itself remained with a canon of Aberdeen cathedral, who possessed the parsonage and vicarage teinds of all four pendicles, but only the parsonage teinds of the mother church, the cure being served by a perpetual vicar. The church measures 20.6m by 8.3m with walls 1.0m to 1.3m thick. The foundations on the east side are clearly visible, just protruding through the turf and denote a building of similar dimensions to the church. The North-East corner of the foundations are destroyed.

The hospital today

Sketch plan of the Hospital's location in Kincardine O'Neil and the possible site of an earlier "hospital". This map summarises the locations of the "possible" hospital remains abutted to Auld Kirk / St Mary's / St Erchard's Church and indicates the most likely site for a previous hospital that Alan the Durward refers to in the 1233 Charter. 1. Route of Drove or Heritage route from the south over Cairn O'Mount through Kincardine O'Neil to the north. 2. The church of St Erchard or St Mary. St Erchard may have built a church here c. 5th century. 3. The possible location of a "hospital" adjacent to a bridge over the River De built by Thomas de Lundin ( Durward) c1225/ 1230. 4. The visible ruins of what appears to be a hospital abutted to the "old" church.

Taken together with the other sources above, this Hospital must be seen as a significant medieval establishment. It served a number purposes; especially the provision of a sub-monastic care home for locals. There is no clear evidence about the inclusion of women. The location of the hospital adjacent to a river crossing on the drove road indicates that it was a travellers inn. The hospital at Soutra Aisle in the Scottish Borders served a similar purpose. In addition to being a Traveller's Inn, it may have been a Chantry for the Cathedral in Old Aberdeen.

See also

• Bishop Dunbar's Hospital
• Beggars Badges
• Soutra Aisle
• Bede House, Old Aberdeen
• Medieval Hospitals in Scotland
• Hospital Chantry
• Mitchell's Hospital Old Aberdeen
• Hospital of St John the Baptist, Arbroath

Further reading

• Alexander, William M., and Third Spalding Club (Aberdeen Scotland). The Place- Names of Aberdeenshire. Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press, 1952.
• Clay, Rotha Mary. The Medieval Hospitals of England. The Antiquary's Books. London,: Methuen & co., 1909.
• Colvin, H. "The Origin of Chantries." Journal of Medieval History 26, no. 2 (2000): 163-173.
• Cowan, Ian Borthwick, David Edward Easson, and Richard Neville Hadcock.
• Medieval Religious Houses, Scotland with an Appendix on the Houses in
• the Isle of Man. 2nd ed. London: Longman, 1976. Cowan, Ian Borthwick, and James Kirk. The Medieval Church in Scotland.
• Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1995. Crouch, D. "The Origin of Chantries: Some Further Anglo-Norman Edivence."
• Journal of Medieval History 27 (2001): 159-180. Dinnie, Robert. History of Kincardine O'neil. Aberdeen: Smith, 1885. Fawcett, Richard. Scottish Medieval Churches : Architecture & Furnishings.
• Stroud: Tempus, 2002. Fawcett, Richard, and Great Britain. Scottish Development Dept. Scottish
• Medieval Churches : An Introduction to the Ecclesiastical Architecture of the 12th to 16th Centuries in the Care of the Secretary of State for Scotland. [Edinburgh]
• Edinburgh: Historic Buildings and Monuments Directorate H.M.S.O., 1985. Fawcett, Richard, and Paul Mellon Centre for Studies in British Art. The
• Architecture of the Scottish Medieval Church, 1100-1560. New Haven.
• Conn. ; London: Yale University Press, 2011. Geddes, Jane. Deeside and the Mearns : An Illustrated Architectural Guide.
• Edinburgh: Rutland Press, 2001. Hall, D. "Unto Yone Hospitall at the Tounis End: The Scottish Medieval Hospital."
• Tayside and Fife Archeological Journal 12 (2006): 89-105. Hall, Derek. Scottish Monastic Landscapes. Stroud: Tempus, 2006. Jervise, Andrew. Epitaphs and Inscriptions from Old Buildings in the North_East
• of Scotland with Historical, Biographical, Genealogical and Antiquarian Notes, Also an Appendix of Illustrative Papers. 3? vols. Vol. 2, Edinburgh: Edmnston & Douglas, 1875.
• MacDonald, James, Donald MacKinnon, and Charles Edward Troup. Place Names of West Aberdeenshire. New Spalding Club. [Publications, No. 21]. Aberdeen,: Printed for the New Spalding Club, 1899.
• McAleese, Ray. "St Mary's Hospital Kincardine O'neil." Scottish Local History Journal April (2015): 12-20.
• McAleese, Ray. "The Hidden Hospitals of Kincardine O'neil." The Leopard 420, no. 420 (2015): 26-28.
• Prescott, E. C. "Medieval Hospitals and Almshouses: The Changing Scene, C. 1200-C. 1640." M.Phil., University of Southampton (United Kingdom), 1988.
• Rowling, Marjorie, and John Mansbridge. Everyday Life of Medieval Travellers. London: Batsford, 1971.
• Salter, Mike. The Old Parish Churches of Scotland. Malvern, Worcs.: Folly
• Publications, 1994. Scottish Record Society., and Ian Borthwick Cowan. The Parishes of Medieval
• Scotland. Publications. Edinburgh,1967. Simpson, William Douglas. The Province of Mar : Being the Rhind Lectures. In Archaeology, 1941 [in Language: English.]. Aberdeen University: Studies.
• Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press, 1943. Simpson, William Douglas. The Ancient Stones of Scotland. 2nd ed. London ; Hale,1968. Sinclair, John. The Statistical Account of Scotland. Drawn up from the
• Communications of the Ministers of the Different Parishes. By Sir John Sinclair. Edinburgh: printed and sold by William Creech; and also sold by J. Donaldson, and A. Guthrie; T. Cadell, J. Stockdale, J. Debrett, and J. Sewel, London; Dunlop and Wilson, Glasgow; Angus and Son; Aberdeen, 1791.
• Spalding Club (Aberdeen Scotland), and Cosmo Innes. Registrum Episcopatus Aberdonensis : Ecclesia Cathedralis Aberdonensis: Regesta Que Extant in Unum Collecta. Spalding Club. Edinburgh: Spalding Club, 1845.
• Watson, William J. The History of the Celtic Place-Names of Scotland. New ed. new ed: Birlinn, 1993.

Notes

References

External links

• See Bede House in entry on Higham Ferrers