Hypoallergenic dog breed

Poodles are well-known for their minimally shedding, single coat, and popular parents for designer dogs marketed as 'allergy-friendly'.

The term hypoallergenic dog breed is commonly used to refer to a dog breed (or crossbreed) that is more compatible with allergic people than other breeds. However, prominent allergen researchers have claimed that there is no basis to the claims that certain dog breeds are hypoallergenic^[1][2] and, while allergen levels vary among individual dogs, the breed is not a significant factor.^[3]

The myth

Though some studies suggest the possible existence of hypoallergenic dog breeds, there is too much variability to conclude that such a breed exists.^[2] According to researchers, claims about the existence of hypoallergenic dog breeds may have been fueled by unsubstantiated articles on the internet.^[2] In a recent interview, Christine Cole Johnson, Senior Staff Scientist at the Henry Ford Hospital & Health System, referring to the findings of her article in the July 2011 issue of the American Journal of Rhinology and Allergy, explained that it was unclear where the name hypoallergenic dog breed came from, and asserted that the existence of such a breed was just a myth.^[1] The significant allergens are proteins found in the dog's saliva and dander.^[4][5] Some studies have suggested that the production of the allergen, and therefore human allergenic reaction, varies by breed,^[6][7][8][9] yet more recent scientific findings indicate that there are no significant differences between breeds in the generation of these allergens.^[1][2][3] One study found hypoallergenic breeds to have significantly more allergen in their coats than non-hypoallergenic breeds although there was no differences in the allergen levels in the air or on the floor.^[10]

Scientific findings

Breeds that shed less are more likely to be hypoallergenic, since the dog's dander and saliva stick to the hair and are not released into the environment.^[11] However, protein expression levels play a major role and amount of shedding alone does not determine degree of allergic reaction. "Even if you get a hairless dog, it's still going to produce the allergen," Dr. Wanda Phipatanakul, chair of the Indoor Allergen Committee for the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology is quoted in the newsmagazine U.S. News & World Report as saying.^[12] How hypoallergenic a particular dog is for a particular person may vary with the individual dog and the individual person.^[13]

If a person is allergic, they may be best able to tolerate a specific dog, possibly of one of the hypoallergenic breeds. Dr. Thomas A. Platts-Mills, head of the Asthma and Allergic Disease Center at the University of Virginia, explained that there are cases in which a specific dog (not breed) might be better tolerated by a specific person, for unknown reasons. "We think there really are differences in protein production between dogs that may help one patient and not another," Dr. Platts-Mills said.^[13]

All dogs shed, and all dogs produce dander and saliva in some degree.^[14] As noted above, the amount of the allergenic protein present on the dander and in saliva varies by breed. Also, the amount of the allergen can be reduced or eliminated in individual dogs by treatments such as bathing.^[15][16] But for most breeds, when not regularly bathed, even a dog who sheds very little or has little dander can trigger a reaction in a sensitive person.^[17]

Effect of size

Size may be a factor in determining hypoallergenicity. It is possible that the total body surface area of the dog is more indicative of reduced production of allergens than its breed.^[18]

Smaller dogs will also leave fewer environmental pollutants containing dog dander and dog allergens (reduced fecal matter, urine and saliva). Small hairless dogs may be less likely to cause allergic reactions "because it's so easy to bathe them and the dander falls off them."^[19] Dogs may leave behind urine, saliva and fecal matter as allergen sources.^[20][21][22] Dogs with access to the outdoors may introduce outdoor allergens such as mold and pollen with larger animals tracking in more of these allergens.^[23] It is well established that most individuals with dog allergy also suffer with additional environmental allergies.^[24] Individuals with dog allergy may also be at increased risk for human protein hypersensitivity with cross-reactivity of dog dander allergen and human seminal fluid.^[25]

Expert recommendations

Researchers have shown that frequently bathing dogs reduces the amount of allergen related protein on the fur or hair of the dog and the amount of airborne allergen.^[16] Bathing a dog at least twice a week will minimize or even eliminate the reaction of an allergic person to a dog.^[15]

Frequent cleaning and vacuuming of the home, using air filters, restricting the dog to certain rooms, and adopting a small dog that can easily be given frequent baths are all recommended by the Humane Society of the United States to control allergens.^[26] Scientific research has repeatedly shown that good cleaning practices in the home remove allergens from the environment.^{[16][27][28][29]}

Many allergists suggest that a dog not be introduced to the environment of a dog allergic individual. While "allergy shots" can reduce many individuals' dog-allergic reactions, the most common approach remains avoidance.

There have been recent studies suggesting early introduction of pets to home may reduce the likelihood of developing sensitization.^[30] There are reports of individuals who will become less sensitive with continued exposure to a pet in the environment. But allergists warn that pet owners cannot rely on a breed being non-allergenic just because a particular allergic pet owner can tolerate a specific dog of that breed.^[13]

See also

• Coat (dog)
• Designer dog
• Hypoallergenic cats
• List of dog breeds
• List of allergies
• List of dog breeds with little to no shedding

References

External links

• Mayo Clinic, Pet allergy
• - ASPCA Allergies