2009 Aviastar British Aerospace BAe 146 crash

2009 Aviastar British Aerospace BAe 146 crash

An Aviastar British Aerospace BAe 146, similar to the aircraft involved in the accident
Occurrence summary
Date	9 April 2009
Summary	Pilot error, CRM failure
Site	Pikei Hill, Tengah Mountain, Wamena, Indonesia 04°02′18″S 138°56′47″E / 4.03833°S 138.94639°E / -4.03833; 138.94639Coordinates: 04°02′18″S 138°56′47″E / 4.03833°S 138.94639°E / -4.03833; 138.94639
Passengers	0
Crew	6
Fatalities	6 (all)
Survivors	0 (none)
Aircraft type	British Aerospace 146-300
Operator	Aviastar
Registration	PK-BRD
Flight origin	Sentani Airport, Jayapura, Indonesia
Destination	Wamena Airport, Wamena, Indonesia

The 2009 Aviastar British Aerospace BAe 146 crash occurred on 9 April 2009, when a British Aerospace BAe 146 crashed into Pikei Hill during a ferry flight from Sentani Airport to Wamena Airport, both in Papua province. Due to the force of the impact the aircraft was totally destroyed and all 6 crew members were killed. The aircraft was carrying voting paper to Wamena as well as several other goods, as a parliamentary election was held in the month. The wreckage was found in Pikei Hill, Tengah Mountain, Tangma, Yahukimo District.^[1]

The accident was the first fatal crash for Aviastar and was the second airliner crash in Indonesia within a week, after an Indonesian Air Force Fokker 27 crashed into a hangar at Bandung on 6 April, killing all 24 people on board.

A final report by the National Transportation Safety Committee (NTSC) concluded that the crash was due to Controlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT) resulting from pilot error. The Captain ignored the ground proximity warning after the First Officer had warned him many times as he became anxious about how the Captain was handling the aircraft.^[2]

Accident

The BAe 146-300, registered PK-BRD, was being operated by Aviastar on a ferry flight from Sentani Airport, Jayapura to Wamena Airport, Wamena. The crew consisted of two pilots, two flight attendants, a flight engineer, and a load master. Captain Sigit Triwahyono was the handling pilot and First Officer Lukman Yusuf was the support/monitoring pilot.^[3][4](p2)

The flight was being operated under Instrument Flight Rules (IFR) from Sentani, and a visual descent, approach, and landing at Wamena, because there was no published instrument approach procedure at Wamena. There was low cloud on the final approach track to Runway 15 at Wamena. The aircraft was observed conducting a low altitude go-around over the runway: it then climbed to a low height along the extended centre-line to the south east, before making a right turn onto the downwind leg of the circuit. As it began its second approach it hit Pikei Hill in Tengah Mountain at 07:43 local time (10:43 UTC). All on board were killed instantly.^[5][6](p2)

Aircraft

The aircraft involved in the accident while still in operation with British European Airways as G-JEBC, pictured in Paris-Charles de Gaulle Airport in 2000

The aircraft involved in the accident was a British Aerospace BAe 146 series 300. It had been manufactured in 1990 and was delivered to Thai Airways International in 1991 as HS-TBO with the name Lahan Sai. Subsequently it was sold to Jersey European Airways in 1998 and then to British European Airways as G-JEBC. It was later sold to Flybe and in 2007 it was bought by Aviastar. It was registered in Indonesia as PK-BRD. At the time of the accident, the aircraft had accumulated a total flying hours of 22.225 flying hours. The aircraft has an airworthiness license issued in January 2009. Originally built as a passenger aircraft, Aviastar modified the aircraft into a combined passenger and cargo configuration in September 2008.^{[7](p5)[8][9][10]}

The aircraft was in the 42-passenger and cargo configuration. However, the weight used for the accident flight was the chart for the aircraft in a 110-passenger configuration. That was therefore the incorrect chart for calculation of the actual configuration of the accident flight.^[11](p6)

Passengers and Crews

Because the aircraft was conducting a ferry flight there were no passengers on the aircraft; on board were six crew members, all Indonesian. The Captain, Sigit Triwahyono, was a 56 years old male with a total flying experience of 8,305 hours, of which 958 were on the BAe146, The First Officer, Lukman Yusuf, was a 49 years old male with a total flying experience of 12,389 hours, 191 on the BAe146 .^{[12][13](p4–5)}

Investigation

The investigation was conducted by the National Transportation Safety Committee. At the time of the accident the weather in Wamena was calm, with slight haze and broken clouds surrounding the area. Visibility was 8 km. The weather was not a factor in the crash. Investigators retrieved both the Flight Data Recorder and Cockpit Voice Recorder. Both had good quality data. Based on the analysis of the flight recorders, investigators then made the chronological order as follows:^{[14](p12–14,19–20)}

At its first attempt to land, the runway in Wamena was obscured by low clouds. Knowing that the crews couldn't fly the aircraft to the established flight path for an approach, the crew abandoned the approach and started a go around to the right at a low height, approx 46 m (150 ft). Whilst on the right circuit down-wind leg, the EGPWS warning sounded, eight of them were "Don't sink", two "Too low terrain", two "Bank Angle" and one "Terrain Terrain" voice aural alerts. The flight crew did not respond to any of those alerts. First Officer Lukman became really concerned with Captain Sigit's handling of the aircraft. He later said "be careful, Sir" to Captain Sigit.^{[15](p12–14,19–20)}

The aircraft then increased its bank angle to the right. First Officer Lukman became really anxious, saying "Sir Sir Sir open Sir left left". Shortly afterwards Captain Sigit banked the aircraft to the left. The "Don't sink" alert sounded for the second time. The bank angle to the left became extreme, exceeding 40°. The aircraft also entered a 10-degree nose down pitch attitude. First Officer Lukman then warned Captain Sigit "don't sink". In repeating the words "don't sink", First Officer Lukman was alerting Captain Sigit to comply with the EGPWS voice aural alert "Don't sink, don't sink". Captain Sigit immediately responded "ya, ya".^{[16](p12–14,19–20)}

Three seconds later, Lukman urgently commanded "left turn". The EGPWS voice alert then sounded, " Too low, terrain", "bank angle, bank angle" "terrain - terrain" warning. At the same time, First Officer called to Captain Sigit "sir! sir! sir!". The aircraft then impacted the ground.^{[17](p12–14,19–20)}

NTSC noted that there was not good crew resource management throughout the flight. Both pilots were also not trained sufficiently in handling the aircraft when the EGPWS warning alert sounded. The Company Operations Manual (COM) specified that the crew briefing should be updated if changing circumstances so required. Captain Sigit did update the briefing when the first approach was discontinued and the go-around was conducted. Captain Sigit's disregard of the EGPWS alerts that sounded as the aircraft was being maneuvered was in non-conformance with the instructions for crew response to EGPWS alerts and cautions, as published in the COM. That, together with their lack of flight crew training in EGPWS, meant that they had not been properly prepared to respond in a timely and appropriate manner to the alerts and warnings provided by the EGPWS. Had Captain Sigit executed the appropriate responses to those EGPWS alerts it is unlikely that the crash would have occurred.^[18](p22)

Both flight crew members didn't conform with the instructions about flight crew responsibilities during a visual approach, as published in the COM. This resulted in the flight crew being unable to assure the safety of flight at low level while manoeuvring the aircraft in a close proximity with terrain in conditions of reduced visibility. Both flight crew members didn't conform to the instructions about flight crew coordination, as also outlined in the COM. Had the flight crew carefully planned the second approach, and closely cooperated with each other, they may have achieved a safe approach and landing. The flight crew's disregard of the published procedures bypassed the safety criteria and inbuilt risk treatments in the design of those procedures.^[19](p22)

See also

• Mount Salak Sukhoi Superjet 100 crash
• Santa Barbara Airlines Flight 518
• 2008 Conviasa Boeing 737 crash

References